An evaluation of role of the informational components in decision-making process of health systems’ managers based on World Health Organization’s standards

Razieh Mirzaeian, Mahboobeh Habibi, Mina Shirvani, Javad Sharifi-Rad

Abstract


Background:Objective of current study was to enhance the effectiveness of the organization its goals, health system managers must possess sufficient knowledge about health information systems which are regarded as the basis of decision-making at different managerial levels. The present research tried to explore the extent of meeting the information management components and evaluate its role in decision-making of health systems' managers.

Methods:Descriptive-analytical in nature, this study intended to examine the urban and rural health centers as well as health system. Data were collected through a self-designed checklist produced based on the World Health Organization’s standards which include the information presentation (6 components), information interpretation (5 components) and using information in decision-making process (1 component) for urban and rural health centers. The checklist designed for health system included needs-analysis and information collection, presentation, processing and interpretation components. The gathered data were then put into SPSS version of 13 and analyzed using independent t-test.

Results:The findings of the study revealed that compared to urban centers, the rural health centers had a higher level in meeting the components in 3 main areas i.e. information presentation, information interpretation and information use in decision-making process (P <0.05). As far as sub-measures were concerned, the rural health centers gained a higher mean score for data presentation in the health system and other interpretation-related components (P <0.05). The level of meeting data presentation components revealed that the mean score for using data for decision-making purposes was high while the mean score for data processing was found to be low.  

Conclusion: Proper processing and appropriate use of data in the decision-making by the managers and public policy-makers are the missing requirements which must be taken into account.

 


Keywords


Data presentation, Data interpretation, Decision-making by the managers, Health system

Full Text:

PDF

References


Lippeveld T, Sauerborn R, Bodart C. Design and implementation of health information systems. In: Lippeveld T, Sauerborn R. Bodart C, eds. WHO Information. Geneva: Wold Health organization; 2000: 1-2.

Hanmer Lyn. Criteria for the evaluation of district health information systems. Int Med Inform. 2000;56:161-8.

Omar MA, Charimari LS, Pinto A. The district health information system and its potential in the management of district and rural hospitals. United Kingdom J World Hosp. 2001;30(3):15-20.

Heywood A, Rohde J. Using information for action: a manual for health workers at facility level. In: Heywood A, Rohde J, eds. Health Information Systems Program. Bellville, South Africa: University of the Western Cape; 2002: 1-123.

Klauche DN. Guidelines for evaluating surveillance systems. Morb Mort Weekly Rep. 1988;37:1-18.

World Health Organization. Report of the interregional meeting on strengthening district health systems based on primary health care, Harare, Zimbabwe. In: WHO, eds. WHO Report. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2000: 1-42.

Picheral HE. Place, space and health. Soc Sci Med. 2004;39:1589-90.

World Health Organization. Rapid evaluation method guidelines for maternal and child health, family planning and other health services. In: WHO, eds. WHO Guideline. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2000: 1-30.

Govind Salik. National health management information system in Mongolia: issues, challenges and opportunities. In: Govind Salik, eds. Bi-Regional Consulation on Strengthening Health Information System in Asia and Pacific. Bangkok: Bangkok Press; 2004: 13-16.

Muquingue, Humberto. Overview of the HISD district health information systems, 2007. Available at: www.houstonisd.org/.

Twaakyondo HM. DHIS Customization Tanzanian experience, 2003. Available at: http://www.hispkerala.org/conference/presentations/country%20presentatiion.

Shaw Vincent. health information system reform in south Africa: developing an essential data set. Bull WHO. 2005;83:632-9.

World Health Organization. The challenge of implementation: district health systems for primary care. In: Janovsky, Katja, eds. WHO Review. Geneva: World Health Organization. 1998: 1-71.

Barron P, Hanmer L, Mahomed H, Braa J. District health information system guidelines, 2001. Available at: ftp://ftp.hst.org.za/pubs/other/dhis/dhis.pdf.

Tugwell P. The measurement interactive loop: a framework for the critical appraisal of need, benefits, and costs of health interventions. J Chron Dis. 2005;38:339-51.

Stinson W. Information systems in primary health care. In: Stinson W, eds. International Health Programs. Washington DC: American Public Health Association; 1983: 1-76.

Odhiambo GW. Evaluation criteria for district health management information systems: Int J Med Inform. 2005;74(1):31-8.

Smith DL, Hansen H, Karim MS. Management information support for district health system based on primary health care. In: Smith DL, Hansen H, Karim MS, eds. Health System. 3rd ed. Geneva: Agakhan foundation; 2004: 89-110.

Dunn WN. The two communities’ metaphor and models of knowledge use: an exploratory case survey. J Knowl. 2005;1:515-36.

Richard E. Cibulskis. Information is not only for manager. Bull WHO. 2005;83(8):637-8.

Ho TJ. Managing health and family planning delivery through a management information system. In: Ho TJ, eds. Health System. Washington DC: World Bank; 1985.

Frère JJ. Health and management information system for child survival project in Pakistan. In: Frère JJ, eds. Technologies for Primary Health Care Project. 2nd ed. Washington DC: United States Agency for Informational Development; 2007: 1-23.