Pelvic bone indices as effective parameters of sex determination in skeletal remains: a cross-sectional study

Kishan R. Siddapur, Geetha K. Siddapur

Abstract


Background: With racial differences, it’s difficult to implement a uniform method for determining sex. Therefore, the need for present study to be carried out was felt. An attempt has been made by carrying out this study to arrive at appropriate conclusions regarding sex determination using dry hip bones representing South-Eastern India (Kancheepuram district region of Tamil Nadu) in relation to the two important indices, the Coxal index (CI), and the Genoves' sciatic notch index(GSI).

Methods: Material for the cross-sectional study included 25 dry hip bones of known gender (left sided were 14, right were 11, male hip bones were 15, and female were 10). Coxal index, Genoves' sciatic notch index, Mean and standard deviation (SD) for the indices were calculated. Significance of these indices in sex determination of the hip bones was assessed implementing unpaired t test.

Results: When unpaired t test was applied on the mean and standard deviation of Coxal & Genove’s sciatic notch indices of the two groups, Males (n=15) & Females (n=10), the result was statistically very significant.

Conclusions: Coxal index values of our present study can be reliably applied for sex determination of dry hip bones of Indian origin. But, our study values can be considered more reliable when using Genoves’ sciatic notch index in determining sex of hip bones of South-Eastern region only (keeping racial variations in mind).

 


Keywords


Pelvic, Coxal, Genoves’ sciatic notch index

Full Text:

PDF

References


Trancho I, Robledo B, Bueis I, Sanchez A. Sexual determination of femur using discriminant functions: Analysis of a Spanish population of known sex and age. JForensic Sci 1997; 42(2):181-185.

Issac B. Biometry of the posterior border of the human hip bone: normal values and their use in sex determination. J Anat Soc India 2002; 51: 43-46.

Derry D. On sexual and racial characters of human ilium. J Anat 1923;58:71-83.

Straus L. Human ilium: sex and stock. Am J Phy Anthrop 1927;11:1-28.

Jovanovic S, Zivanovic S. The establishment of sex by greater sciatic notch. Acta Anat 1965;61:101-7.

Jovanovic S, Zivanovic S, Lotric N. The upper part of greater sciatic notch in sex determination of pathologically deformed hip bones. Acta Anat 1968;69:229-238.

Singh S, Potturi R. Greater sciatic notch in sex determination. J Anat 1978;125:619-624.

Schulter P, Hayek A, Schimidt J, Caraig J. Determination of sex with a discriminant analysis of new pelvic bone measurement. I J For Sci 1983;28: 169-180.

Turner W. The index of the pelvic brim as a basis of classification. J Anat 1886;20:125-143.

Pal P, Bose S, Choudhary M. Sexing of adult hip bone. European Journal of Morphology 2004;2:16-18.

Varodompun N, Thinley T, Visutipol B, Ketmalasiri B, Pattarabunjerd N. Correlation between the acetabular diameter and thickness in Thais. J Orthop Surg 2002; 10: 41-44.

Msamati C, Igbigbi S, Lavy B. Geometric measurements of the acetabulum in adult Malawians: radiographic study. East Afr Med J 2003; 80: 546-549.

Washburn L. Sex differences in the pubic bone of Bantu and Bushman. Am J Phys Anthropol 1949; 7: 425-432.

Davivongs V. The pelvic girdle of the Australian aborigine; sex differences and sex determination. Am J Phys Anthropol 1963; 21: 443-455.

Shah S, Zalawadia A, Ruparelia S, Patel S, Rathod S, Patel S. Morphometric study of greater sciatic notch of dry human hip bone in Gujarat region. NJIRM 2011; 2(2):27-30.

Singh D, Singh P, Singh Z. Morphometry of the adult human dry hip bone. International Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences 2013;5:505-507.