DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18203/2320-6012.ijrms20182285

Comparative study of effectiveness of pap smear versus visual inspection with acetic acid for mass screening of lesions of cervix

Mercy Mrudula Dasari, Venkatalakshmi Anem, Sirisha Gunta, Satish Kumar Seeram, Bhagyalakshmi Atla

Abstract


Background: Cervical cancer is a leading cause of morbidity and mortality among women worldwide and more over in the developing countries, so there is a need to develop screening test with high specificity and sensitivity. Aim of the study was to evaluate the effectiveness of Papanicolaou (PAP) smear versus visual inspection acetic acid (VIA) for screening cervical lesions in patients and to determine and compare their sensitivity and specificity.

Methods: The present study is a hospital based prospective study for a period of two years at the department of pathology from August 2014 to July 2016 consisting of 500 patients attending gynaecology outpatient clinic. Papanicolaou (Pap) smear tests and visual inspection acetic acid were employed along with complete clinical history record. The results of VIA were correlated with that of pap smear on the basis of sensitivity, specificity and positive and negative predictive value.

Results: Out of 500 cases, most common age group was 21 to 40 years of age consisting of 305 cases - 61%. VIA was positive in 156 cases-31.2%, PAP smear positive for epithelial cell abnormalities were 60 cases-12%. VIA showed higher sensitivity (52.38%) compared to Pap smear (40%) whereas Pap smear showed higher specificity (93.2%) compared to VIA (92.4%).

Conclusions: Papanicolaou test is a better screening test for epithelial cell abnormality than VIA. However, in countries with low resource settings where cytology-based screening programs are not available, VIA is a promising alternative.


Keywords


Acetic acid, Cervical cancer, Papanicolaou smear

Full Text:

PDF

References


Sankaranarayanan R, Budukh AM, Rajkumar R. Effective screening programmes for cervical cancer in low-and middle-income developing countries. Bull World Health Organ. 2001;79(10):954-62.

Ellenson LH, Pirog EC. The female genital tract. Robbins and Cotran Pathologic Basis of Disease, 8th ed. Elsevier. 2010.

Khan MA, Raja FY, Ishfaq G, Tahir F, Subhan F, Kazi BM, et al. PAP Smear Screening for Pre-cancerous Conditions of the Cervical Cancer. Pak J Med Res. 2005;44:111-3.

Gaffikin L, Blumenthal PD, McGrath J, Chirenje ZM. Visual inspection with acetic acid for cervical-cancer screening: Test qualities in a primary care setting. The Lancet. 1999 Mar 13;353(9156):869.

Hakama M, Louhvauri K. A screening programme for cervical cancer that worked. cancer surveys. 1988;7:403-16.

Bhattacharyya AK, Nath JD, Deka H. Comparative study between pap smear and visual inspection with acetic acid (via) in screening of CIN and early cervical cancer. J Mid-life Health. 2015;6:53-8.

Bhatia R, Goel S, Pal S, Sareen AR. Down staging of carcinoma cervix by Pap smear in high risk women. Obs Gynae. 2001;4(1):36-29.

Sankaranarayanan R, Wesley R, Thara S, Dhakad N, Chandralekha B, Sebastian P, et al. Test characteristics of visual inspection with 4% acetic acid (VIA) and Lugol's iodine (VILI) in cervical cancer screening in Kerala, India. Inter J Cancer. 2003 Sep 1;106(3):404-8.

Leena MS, Shafee M, Kokiwar PR, Jogdand GS. Visual Inspection with Acetic Acid (VIA) Vs Cervical Cytology as Cervical Cancer Screening Tools in South India. Ind J Public Health Research Development. 2013 Jul 1;4(3):207.

Kamal Patil, Durdi G, Lakshmi KS, Swamy MK. Comparison of diagnostic efficacy of visual inspection of cervix with acetic acid and pap smear for prevention of cervical cancer: Is VIA Superseding pap smear?. Smear J South Asian Federation Obst and Gynaecol. 2011;3(3):131-4.

Shaheen S, Sharma R, Rashi R. Visual Inspection with Acetic Acid (VIA) in cervical cancer screening in low resource settings. Bangladesh Jo Med Sci. 2014 Jan 1;13(4):454-9.

Saha R, Thapa M. Correlation of cervical cytology with cervical histology. Kathmandu Univ Med J (KUMJ). 2005 Jul-Sep;3(3):222-4.

Bhalerao A, Kulkarni S, Ghike S, Kawathalkar JS. Correlation of pap smear, colposcopy and histopathology in women with unhealthy cervix. J South Asian Feder Obst Gynae. 2012 May;4(2):97-8.

Goel A, Gandhi G, Batra S, Bhambani S, Zutshi V, Sachdeva P. Visual inspection of the cervix with acetic acid for cervical intraepithelial lesions. Int J Gynecol Obstet. 2005;88:25-30

Hegde D, Shetty H, Shetty P K, Rai S. Diagnostic value of acetic acid comparing with conventional Pap smear in the detection of colposcopic biopsy-proved CIN. J Can Res Ther. 2011;7:454-8.

Ceccini S, Bonardi R, Mazzotta A, Grazzini G, Lossa A, Ciato S. Testing cervicography and VIA as screening tests for cervical cancer. Tumori. 1993;79:22-5.

Slawson DC, Bennett JH, Herman JM. Are Papanicolaou smears enough? Acetic acid washes of the cervix as adjunctive therapy: A HARNET study. Harrisburg Area Research Network. J Fam Pract. 1992;35:271-7.

Megavand E, Denny L, Dehaeck K, Soeters R, Bloch B. Acetic acid visualization of the cervix: An alternative to cytologic screening. Obstet Gynecol. 1996;88:383-6.

Consul S, Agrawal A, Sharma H, Bansal A, Gutch M, Jain N. Comparative study of effectiveness of Pap smear versus visual inspection with acetic acid and visual inspection with Lugol's iodine for mass screening of premalignant and malignant lesion of cervix. Ind J Med Paediatr Oncol. 2012;33:161-5.

Denny L, Kuhn L, De Souza M, Pollack AE, Dupree W, Wright TC. Screen-and- treat approaches for cervical cancer prevention in low-resource settings: A randomized controlled trial. JAMA. 2005;294(17):2173.

Singh KN, More S. Visual inspection of cervix with acetic acid in early diagnosis of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia and early cancer cervix. J Obstet Gynaecol India. 2010;60:55-60.

Jeronimo J, Morales O, Horna J, Pariona J, Manrique J, Rubiños J, et al. Visual inspection with acetic acid for cervical cancer screening outside of low-resource settings. Rev Panam Salud Publica. 2005;17:1-5.

Ghosh P, Gandh G, Kochhar PK, Zutshi V, Batra S. Visual inspection of cervix with lugol’siodin for early detection of premalignant and Malignant lesions of cervix. Ind J Med Res 2012;136:265-71.

Basu PS, Sankaranarayanan R, Mandal R, Roy C, Das P, Choudhury D, Bhattacharya D, Chatterjee R, Dutta K, Barik S, Tsu V. Visual inspection with acetic acid and cytology in the early detection of cervical neoplasia in Kolkata, India. International J Gynecol Cancer. 2003 Sep;13(5):626-32.

Arbyn M, Sankarnarayanan R, Muwonge R, Keita N, Dolo A, Mbalawa CG, et al. Pooled analysis of the accuracy of five cervical cancer screening tests assessed in eleven studies in Africa and India. Int J Cancer. 2008;123(1):153-60.

Goldie SJ, Kim JJ, Wright TC. Cost-effectiveness of human papilloma virus DNA testing for cervical cancer screening in women aged 30 years or more. Obstet Gynecol. 2004;103(4):619-31.