DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18203/2320-6012.ijrms20203702

A comprehensive review of the healthy worker effect in occupational epidemiological studies

Fahad Saad Algarni

Abstract


The reduction of mortality and morbidity rates among occupational cohort studies may be attributed to the presence of the healthy worker effect (HWE). Occupational epidemiologic studies investigating worker’s health are prone to the risk of having the HWE phenomenon and this special form of bias has been debated over the years. Hence, it’s imperative to explore in-depth the magnitude and sources of HWE, and further, elucidate the factors that may affect HWE and strategies reducing HWE. The HWE should be considered as a mixed bias between selection and confounding bias. The validity threats due to the HWE among morbidity studies are the same as the mortality studies. The consequent reduction due to the HWE in the association between the exposure and outcome may lead to underestimating some harmful exposures in the workplace or occupational settings. Healthy hire effect and healthy worker survivor effect are the main sources of HWE. Several factors can increase or decrease the probability of HWE; therefore, the investigators should consider them among future occupational epidemiological studies. Many strategies can help in reducing the impact of HWE, but each strategy has its weaknesses and strengths. Not all strategies can be applied among all occupational epidemiological studies. Mathematical procedures still need further investigations to be validated. HWE is a consequence of inappropriate comparison groups in nature. The usage of the general population as a reference group is not an appropriate choice. By considering the HWE sources and factors and using appropriate strategies, the impact of HWE may be reduced.


Keywords


Confounding bias, Healthy worker effect, Healthy worker survivor effect, Occupational epidemiology, Selection bias

Full Text:

PDF

References


Checkoway H, Pearce N, Kriebel D. Research methods in occupational epidemiology. Monographs Epidemiol. 2004.

Li CY, Sung FC. A review of the healthy worker effect in occupational epidemiology. J Occup Med. 1999;49(4):225-9.

Chowdhury R, Shah D, Payal AR. Healthy worker effect phenomenon: revisited with emphasis on statistical methods-a review. IJOEM. 2017;21(1):2.

Nieto FJ. A Dictionary of Epidemiology. Oxford University Press/International Epidemiological Association 978-0-19-531449-6; 289 páginas. Gaceta Sanitaria. 2009;23(3):255.

Eisen EA, Picciotto S, Robins JM. Healthy worker effect. Wiley StatsRef: Statistics Reference Online. 2014.

Ogle W. Letter to the Registrar-General on the mortality in the registration districts of England and Wales during the ten years 1871-80. Supplement to the Forty-Fifth Annual Report of the Registrar-General of Births, Deaths, and Marriages in England. 1885.

McMichael A, Spirtas R, Kupper L. An epidemiologic study of mortality within a cohort of rubber workers, 1964-72. J Occup Environ Med. 1974;16(7):458-64.

McMichael AJ. Standardized mortality ratios and the "healthy worker effect": Scratching beneath the surface. J Occup Med. 1976;18(3):165-8.

Shah D. Healthy worker effect phenomenon. IJOEM. 2009;13(2):77-9.

Gommans F, Jansen N, Stynen D, de Grip A, Kant I. The ageing shift worker: a prospective cohort study on need for recovery, disability, and retirement intentions. Scand J Work Environ Health. 2015:356-67.

Zejda JE, Pahwa P, Dosman JA. Decline in spirometric variables in grain workers from start of employment: differential effect of duration of follow up. J Occup Environ Med. 1992;49(8):576-80.

Choi B. Definition, sources, magnitude, effect modifiers, and strategies of reduction of the healthy worker effect. J Occup Med.1992;34(10):979-88.

Monson RR. Observations on the healthy worker effect. J Occup Med. official publication of the Industrial Medical Association. 1986;28(6):425-33.

Johnson CY, Rocheleau CM, Lawson CC, Grajewski B, Howards PP. Factors affecting workforce participation and healthy worker biases in US women and men. Ann Epidemiol. 2017;27(9):558-62. e2.

Pearce N, Checkoway H, Kriebel D. Bias in occupational epidemiology studies. J Occup Environ Med. 2007;64(8):562-8.

Baillargeon J, Wilkinson GS. Characteristics of the healthy survivor effect among male and female Hanford workers. Am J Ind Med.1999;35(4):343-7.

Choi BC. A technique to re-assess epidemiologic evidence in light of the healthy worker effect: the case of firefighting and heart disease. J Occup Environ Med. 2000;42(10):1021-34.

Guidotti TL. Occupational mortality among firefighters: assessing the association. J Occup Environ Med. 1995;37(12):1348-56.

Delzell E, Monson RR. Mortality among rubber workers IV. General mortality patterns. J Occup Environ Med. 1981;23(12):850-6.

Burns CJ, Bodner KM, Jammer BL, Collins J, Swaen G. The healthy worker effect in US chemical industry workers. J Occup Med. 2011;61(1):40-4.

Brown DM, Picciotto S, Costello S, Neophytou AM, Izano MA, Ferguson JM, et al. The healthy worker survivor effect: target parameters and target populations. Curr Environ Health Rep. 2017;4(3):364-72.

Radon K, Goldberg M, Becklake M. Healthy worker effect in cohort studies on chronic bronchitis. Scand J Work Environ Health. 2002:328-32.

Baillargeon J, Wilkinson G, Rudkin L, Baillargeon G, Ray L. Characteristics of the healthy worker effect: a comparison of male and female occupational cohorts. J Occup Environ Med. 1998;40(4):368-73.

Shah D. Healthy worker effect phenomenon. IJOEM. 2009;13(2):77.

Arrighi HM, Hertz-Picciotto I. The evolving concept of the healthy worker survivor effect. Epidemiol. 1994:189-96.

Sterling TD, Weinkam JJ. The 'healthy worker effect' on morbidity rates. J Occup Med. 1985;27(7):477-82.

Fox AJ, Collier P. Low mortality rates in industrial cohort studies due to selection for work and survival in the industry. J Epidemiol Community Health. 1976;30(4):225-30.

Musk A, Monson R, Peters J, Peters R. Mortality among Boston firefighters, 1915-1975. J Occup Environ Med. 1978;35(2):104-8.

Gilbert E. Some confounding factors in the study of mortality and occupational exposures. Am J epidemiol. 1982;116(1):177-88.

Checkoway H, Mathew RM, Shy CM, Watson JE, Jr., Tankersley WG, Wolf SH, et al. Radiation, work experience, and cause specific mortality among workers at an energy research laboratory. Br J Ind Med. 1985;42(8):525-33.

Peto J, Doll R, Hermon C, Binns W, Clayton R, Goffe T. Relationship of mortality to measures of environmental asbestos pollution in an asbestos textile factory. Ann Occup Hyg. 1985;29(3):305-5.

Marmot MG, Shipley MJ, Rose G. Inequalities in death--specific explanations of a general pattern? Lancet. 1984;1(8384):1003-6.

Ott MG, Holder BB, Langner RR. Determinants of mortality in an industrial population. J Occup Med. 1976;18(3):171-7.

Howe GR, Chiarelli Am, Lindsay JP. Components and modifiers of the healthy worker effect: evidence from three occupational cohorts and implications for industrial compensation. Am J Epidemiol. 1988;128(6):1364-75.

Lea CS, Hertz-Picciotto I, Andersen A, Chang-Claude J, Olsen JH, Pesatori AC, et al. Gender differences in the healthy worker effect among synthetic vitreous fiber workers. Am J Epidemiol. 1999;150(10):1099-106.

Carpenter LM. Some observations on the healthy worker effect. Br J Ind Med. 1987;44(5):289.

Meijers JM, Swaen Gm, Volovics A, Slangen JJ, Van Vliet K. Silica exposure and lung cancer in ceramic workers: a case-control study. Int J Epidemiol. 1990;19(1):19-25.

Hernberg S. Introducción a la epidemiología ocupacional: Ediciones Díaz de Santos; 1995.

Steenland K, Stayner L. The importance of employment status in occupational cohort mortality studies. Epidemiol. 1991:418-23.

Sterling TD, Weinkam JJ. Extent, persistence, and constancy of the healthy worker or healthy person effect by all and selected causes of death. J Occup Med. 1986;28(5):348-53.

Choi BC. Mathematical procedure to adjust for the healthy worker effect: the case of firefighting, diabetes, and heart disease. J Occup Environ Med. 2001;43(12):1057-63.

Chevrier J, Picciotto S, Eisen EA. A comparison of standard methods with g-estimation of accelerated failure-time models to address the healthy-worker survivor effect: application in a cohort of autoworkers exposed to metalworking fluids. Epidemiol. 2012:212-9.